Trader Joe’s, come to Western NY, pretty please with a sun-dried organic cherry on top?


Fearless Flyer

Well, it seems I’ve opened up a can of worms. For the sake of this blog post, the worms would probably be Thai Lime Basil worms, or Trader Jose’s cha-cha chili worms. 

My love affair with Trader Joe’s, the California-based small-scale gourmet supermarket, started nearly 16 years ago. A newcomer to the San Francisco Bay area, my roomate got me hooked on Trader Joe’s quirky products. I didn’t have a car. No one doesn’t have a car in California. But that didn’t stop me. To get to a Trader Joe’s, I would take two lines on the BART, with a small cooler in tow, to get there, where I would purchase delicacies such as frozen tri-colored butternut squash ravioli and mahi-mahi filets. 

Later in life, when we moved back to New Jersey and had a car (because you *really* need a car to get around in NJ), I loved shopping at the Trader Joe’s in Westfield, N.J. 

Now, I live in Rochester. We have Wegman’s, headquarters to the mother of all amazing supermarkets, where my own mother, on her first trip into the cavernous Marketplace section, with its patisserie, brick-oven artisan bakery and 20-foot long Mediterranean olive bar, described Wegmans as “where food goes when it goes to heaven.” Don’t get me wrong, I love Wegman’s. 

But it’s not Trader Joe’s. 

One of my most recent columns was about how and with what to fill the vacant retail spaces around Brighton. Lately, as I drive the stretch of Monroe Ave. between Brighton and Pittsford, I get an empty feeling.  Whether the properties are older; like the former Steve’s restaurant in Brighton, or brand new; such as the Oak Hill Commons in Pittsford, I can’t help but wonder what the holdup is for filling these properties: is it the economy, or local politics? 

 The most glaring of these vacancies is the 11,348 sq.-ft. site of the former Rite Aid in Brighton Commons.  To get some opinions on this for my column, I took a very informal poll of my Facebook friends asking them what they would like to see in this place. One friend wrote: Trader Joes! And then another and another in complete agreement.   

I would love to see this place in the center of Brighton become the nation’s newest Trader Joe’s.   It would be great to walk or bike to a store like this to pick up items ranging from organically grown lettuce, cage-free eggs, a box of gluten-free granola, or even mahi-mahi burgers for the grill. 

 Trader Joe’s was featured on the Sept. 13 cover of Fortune magazine, and described it as one of the nation’s fastest growing retailers. I make a pilgrimage to Trader Joe’s in Long Island whenever I can and ask the manager about the possibility of an opening in Rochester. But the answer is always the same: this privately-held company, which boasts 344 stores in 25 states, fears competition from a certain large-scale supermarket further up Monroe Ave. bearing the name that starts with a W.   But one can always hope. 

I got an enormous number of responses from my column, both via email and others who told me that “yeah! I want Trader Joe’s too!” at the gym, or — lo and behold — in the middle of the produce section at Wegmans! They even asked me how they could help me convince them to come here – like I have an inside track or something. 

So you see, TJ’s – Brighton, NY folks are educated, earthy and slightly crunchy. See why we would need you and support you here? 

One reader wrote in an accused me of starting a crusade of trying to bring yet another chain into town while running the little guy mom and pop markets out of business and told me to stick to writing and stay out of the business development business.  Other readers wrote in and shared their Trader Joe’s love stories, and still others wrote to me with links of articles explaining the complexities of chosing a site for new grocery stores in urban areas. 

So, Trader Joe’s, if you are reading, in spite of Rochester being home to the world’s greatest supermarket chain, there is still room in our hearts for you. So come on up!

Tags: , , ,

About stacylynngittleman

I have been a reporter and public relations professional for over 30 years, specializing in profile features and investigative longform writing. During my career I've profiled WWII Honor Flight Veterans, artists and musicians and have written on topics that range from environmental and gun control issues to Jewish culture. Click around on my writing samples plus read my blog on my personal life raising three kids over 27 years and three cities.

8 responses to “Trader Joe’s, come to Western NY, pretty please with a sun-dried organic cherry on top?”

  1. potenzmittel shop says :

    Simply discovered your web page through Yahoo and I consider this can be a disgrace that you are not ranked upper due to the fact that that is a wonderful post. To switch this I determined to avoid wasting your Site to my RSS reader and I will try to point out you in one of my posts since you actually deserv extra readers when publishing content material of this quality.


  2. pc spiele says :

    Hi, i just thought i’d post and let you know your blogs layout is really messed up on the K-Melonbrowser. Anyhow keep up the good work.


  3. ВИДЕОШОК says :

    Благодарность за материалы! 🙂


  4. Deborah Gabriel says :

    I feel your pain. This evening, I submitted the following letter on Trader Joe’s Website:

    Please…I’m begging.

    I believe this is my third request in the last 18 months, following my move to upstate NY from Seattle. Leaving the Pacific Northwest was hard and one of the hardest things was leaving Trader Joe’s behind.

    Since moving, I’ve made four pilgrimages to Trader Joe’s in different states: Pittsburgh (twice) and Cleveland (twice). Incredibly, those stores are closer to Rochester than to ones in NYC.

    Yes, I now live in the land of Wegman’s but I can’t imagine TJ’s actually fears competition, as it is unique. I regularly Google TJ/Rochester just in case you’ve decided to open one here. I was thrilled today to finally see listings come up under TJ/Rochester and clicked on the links expecting to see happy news. Instead, I found articles and blogs from many other unhappy Rochester-area residents (including the surrounding towns of Brighton, Pittsford, etc) who were all expressing my level of grief and wonderment that, incredibly, there is still no TJ’s in an area that would clearly support it.

    Read the blogs…we want it…we drive 4-6 hours into other states to get our TJ staples. We’ll support a local store. We promise.

    One of the bloggers expressed puzzlement and suggested just exactly the same location I thought would be perfect for a local TJ’s: the Brighton area on Monroe Ave. You’d be mobbed.

    Please, please, please, please, please. Really…Spokane is getting a TJ’s and we aren’t? I’m dangerously close to telling you that if I hit black ice on my next winter trip to Cleveland to stock up, and skid my car into a van full of nuns, puppies, and school-children taking turkeys to the poor…it will be ALL YOUR FAULT!!!!!

    If I got thousands of people to sign a petition, would you come then?

    I was about to sign off with “Thanks”…but you only get one of those when you open a Trader Joe’s here.

    (my signature)…I have grocery money and I know how to use it!


    • transplantednorth says :

      well said, I hope we can start a campaign to get TJ’s here at last, right at 12 corners Brighton! Thanks for reading.


  5. Kelly says :

    Not sure if this is a rumor, but I was recently told Trader Joe’s is coming to Pittsford Plaza. Let’s all keep our fingers for this to actually happen! Move over Wegman!!!!


  6. Pittsford says :

    It’s coming. Really. It is. Pittsford Plaza.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: